20 Questions to Ask a Book Editor Before Signing a Contract

If you're thinking of hiring a book editor before you self-publish your novel, choose carefully. Too often these days scammers are leaping out of the shadows to corner well-meaning writers. So how do you separate the good from the scam? I'm here to help.

How to Approach an Editor

First, get the conversation started by asking the right questions. Many book editors are active on social media, such as Threads, Instagram, or BlueSky. They're happy to field questions, but usually prefer a more professional line of communication (email or website form) rather than a social channel DM.

If an editor doesn't have an answer for most questions on this list, that could signal a red flag. So, dig deeper. Research wisely. View every angle of their digital footprint through a sleuth's lens, and then ask for more information. You can never be too thorough in your quest for an honest partner in your publishing journey!

What to Ask Your Editor

1. Do you have a website?

2. How many authors have you worked with in my genre?

3. Could I read some testimonials or reach out to past clients about working with you?

4. What is your price list?

5. Do you offer discounts for clients?

6. Would you mind sharing a sample contract with me?

7. What is your policy on AI?

8. Do you accept payment in installments?

9. What is your refund policy?

10. How much do you charge up front, and is that in addition to or included in the total quote?

11. How do I get a free sample edit?

12. What kinds of editing do you provide?

13. How often do you communicate during the editing process?

14. What happens after our work together is finished?

15. How far in advance should I book an editing service with you?

16. What state does my novel have to be in for you to work with me?

17. What is your estimated turnaround time for a book of X length?

18. Could we chat over the phone or on a video call sometime?

19. What is your editorial training like?

20. Do you have any extra credentials (editing organizations, editorial platforms, book awards, etc.) under your belt?

    
    

Where to Go Next

It's perfectly okay to approach several editors at once. Not all editors conduct their business the same way, and each person can offer you a unique editing experience. But keep in mind: vibe is also important. If you don't think the editor is a match for your sense of humor, your book's sensitive content, or your spice level, be honest and then part ways gracefully.

Thanks for reading. If you have anything to add to this list, contact me! And know that I'm always in your corner, rooting for every word on the page.